Dhirubhai Ambani was a visionary entrepreneur who transformed India’s industrial landscape. Starting from humble beginnings, Ambani built Reliance Industries, one of India’s largest conglomerates. However, his rise to power was not without controversy. Ambani’s business practices have been scrutinized, debated, and criticized by many over the years. This article highlights Dhirubhai Ambani’s controversies surrounding his business practices. It explores his methods, the ethical questions raised, and the impact of these practices on the Indian business environment.
The stock market manipulation allegations
One of the earliest and most significant of Dhirubhai Ambani’s controversies was the allegation of stock market manipulation. In the late 1970s and early 1980s, Reliance Industries began to grow at an unprecedented rate. As such, its shares became highly sought after. Ambani was known for his innovative approach to raising capital through the stock market. For example, he’d issue convertible debentures that later converted into equity shares.
However, critics accused Ambani of manipulating the stock market to artificially boost the value of Reliance shares. They alleged that Ambani used a network of brokers and benami (proxy) shareholders to corner the market. In so doing, they’d inflate the stock price.
This manipulation allowed Reliance to raise capital at higher valuations, fueling further expansion. The Indian stock market regulator, SEBI (Securities and Exchange Board of India), investigated these allegations. However, no conclusive evidence was found to implicate Ambani directly.
Political Connections and Regulatory Capture
Building relationships with politicians became Ambani’s trademark strategy. You can trace his success to these carefully cultivated connections across party lines. Former finance minister Pranab Mukherjee once called him “a law unto himself.”
License Raj era regulations heavily favored established businesses. Ambani allegedly used political influence to secure favorable licenses and permits. Competitors complained about unfair advantages in government approvals. Import licenses, industrial permits, and tax exemptions often seemed to favor Reliance.
The company’s rapid expansion during the 1980s raised eyebrows. Rivals questioned how Reliance obtained approvals so quickly. Some alleged that Ambani’s political connections bypassed normal regulatory processes. These relationships created a template that many Indian businessmen later followed.
The Polyester Yarn Cartel Controversy
Reliance dominated India’s polyester yarn market during the 1980s. But how did one company achieve such market control? Allegations emerged that Ambani created an artificial shortage to drive up prices.
The strategy involved controlling raw material imports and production capacity. Textile manufacturers had no choice but to buy at inflated prices. Small-scale producers particularly suffered from these alleged practices. In fact, many went out of business due to high input costs.
Government investigations revealed suspicious import patterns. Reliance would sometimes import materials at inflated prices from related companies. These transactions helped move money abroad while claiming higher production costs. The practice demonstrated how regulatory gaps could be exploited.
The V.P. Singh controversy
Dhirubhai Ambani’s political connections came under intense scrutiny during the tenure of Prime Minister V.P. Singh in the late 1980s. Singh served as the Finance Minister before becoming Prime Minister. He initiated a series of investigations into Reliance Industries for allegations of tax evasion and customs duty violations.
The most notable controversy during this period was the “Wadia vs. Ambani” case. Nusli Wadia, the head of Bombay Dyeing, accused Ambani of manipulating government policies to favor Reliance. Wadia alleged that Ambani had used his influence to secure lower import duties on raw materials. The case became a major political issue, with Singh’s government launching a full-scale investigation into Reliance Industries.
While the investigations did uncover some irregularities, no substantial legal action was taken against Ambani. However, the controversy highlighted the extent of Ambani’s influence over the political and regulatory apparatus in India.
The war with Bombay Dyeing
The rivalry between Dhirubhai Ambani and Nusli Wadia of Bombay Dyeing is another famous business feud in Indian history. The two industrialists engaged in a bitter battle for dominance in the polyester industry during the 1980s and 1990s. However, the rivalry was not only about market share, but also about influencing government policies, media narratives, and public perception.
Wadia accused Ambani of engaging in unethical business practices. These included lobbying for favorable government policies, manipulating stock prices, and using strong-arm tactics to crush competition. The battle between Reliance and Bombay Dyeing played out in the media. Both sides used their connections to influence public opinion.
The rivalry reached its peak when Wadia filed a lawsuit against Ambani, accusing him of violating customs regulations. Both sides presented evidence and counter-evidence in court, and Ambani ultimately emerged victorious. The controversy cemented Ambani’s reputation as a businessman willing to push the boundaries of legality to achieve his goals.
The allegations of tax evasion
Another of Dhirubhai Ambani’s controversies is the tax evasion allegations that plagued his career. Several reports surfaced accusing Reliance Industries of underreporting income, inflating expenses, and using offshore entities to evade taxes. The Indian tax authorities conducted multiple investigations into these allegations, but Ambani consistently denied any wrongdoing.
One significant case of alleged tax evasion involved the import of plant and machinery for Reliance’s petrochemical plants. Reliance had allegedly under-invoiced the imports to reduce customs duties and evade taxes. The case led to a protracted legal battle, with the tax authorities claiming that Reliance owed millions in unpaid taxes.
Despite the investigations and legal battles, Ambani managed to avoid any major legal consequences. Critics argued that his ability to escape punishment was proof of his influence over India’s political and legal systems.
The Dhirubhai Ambani vs. Indian Express feud
The Indian Express was one of the few newspapers that openly criticized Ambani’s business practices. They published a series of investigative reports that alleged financial irregularities, political manipulation, and unethical behavior by Reliance Industries.
In turn, Ambani used his influence to launch a counter-offensive against the Indian Express. Reliance reportedly withdrew advertisements from the newspaper, leading to significant financial losses for the publication. Ambani’s supporters also launched a public relations campaign to discredit the Indian Express and its editor.
The impact on Indian business ethics
Dhirubhai Ambani’s business methods permanently altered Indian corporate culture. You can see his influence in how companies approach regulation today. His aggressive tactics normalized certain questionable practices.
Minority shareholder rights became a major concern after Reliance controversies. The company’s complex ownership structures often diluted small investor interests. Additionally, related party transactions became common among Indian conglomerates. These deals frequently favored controlling shareholders over minority investors.
SEBI strengthened disclosure requirements partly due to Reliance-related issues. Corporate governance norms evolved to address manipulation tactics. Independent directors and audit committees became mandatory. These changes aimed to prevent the concentration of power that Ambani wielded.
The legacy of Dhirubhai Ambani
Despite Dhirubhai Ambani’s controversies, his legacy as a pioneering entrepreneur remains intact. He transformed Reliance Industries into a global conglomerate, creating jobs, wealth, and opportunities for millions of Indians.
However, Ambani’s legacy is also a reminder of the ethical dilemmas that can arise in the pursuit of business success. The controversies that dogged his career serve as cautionary tales for future generations of entrepreneurs. They also highlight the importance of ethical business practices and the need for transparency and accountability in corporate governance.
How do Dhirubhai Ambani’s controversies compare to those of other global business leaders?
Dhirubhai Ambani’s controversies are mostly rooted in the specific context of India’s economic and regulatory environment. However, they highlight common challenges that arise when navigating the intersection of business, politics, and ethics on a large scale. Below are some key comparisons between Dhirubhai Ambani’s controversies and those of other notable global business leaders.
1. John D. Rockefeller (Standard Oil)
John D. Rockefeller, the founder of Standard Oil, faced significant controversies over his monopolistic practices. These controversies led to the U.S. government breaking up Standard Oil under antitrust laws in 1911. Rockefeller was accused of using ruthless tactics to eliminate competition. These included price-fixing, predatory pricing, and securing favorable railroad rates.
Like Ambani, Rockefeller built an empire in a rapidly growing industry (oil for Rockefeller, petrochemicals and textiles for Ambani). Both were accused of using aggressive and sometimes unethical tactics to gain market dominance.
Rockefeller’s practices led to legal action and the breakup of his company. However, Ambani was able to navigate his controversies without facing such drastic consequences. Both leaders, however, left behind legacies that have significantly shaped their respective industries.
2. Rupert Murdoch (News Corporation)
Rupert Murdoch, the media mogul behind News Corporation, has faced numerous controversies. These include allegations of unethical journalism practices, such as phone hacking and political manipulation. He’s also been accused of exerting undue influence over public opinion through his media outlets.
Like Ambani, Murdoch was known for his close relationships with political figures, which he leveraged to further his business interests. Both were criticized for blurring the lines between business and politics.
While Murdoch’s controversies primarily involved media and journalism ethics, Ambani’s were centered around market manipulation and regulatory exploitation. Both, however, demonstrated the immense power that comes with controlling significant industry sectors.
3. Bill Gates (Microsoft)
Bill Gates, co-founder of Microsoft, faced antitrust allegations in the late 1990s and early 2000s. The U.S. government accused Microsoft of using its dominance in the PC operating system market to stifle competition.
Gates, like Ambani, was a visionary leader who built a dominant company in a critical industry. Both faced accusations of using their market power to engage in anti-competitive practices. Gates’ controversies resulted in legal challenges and a landmark antitrust case. However, Dhirubhai Ambani’s controversies, while significant, did not lead to similar legal repercussions. Additionally, Gates’ later focus on philanthropy contrasts with Ambani’s legacy, which remains more business-centric.
4. Carlos Slim (Grupo Carso)
Carlos Slim has faced criticism for his monopolistic control over Mexico’s telecommunications industry. His company, América Móvil, was accused of charging high prices and limiting competition. These allegations led to regulatory scrutiny and calls for reform.
Both Slim and Ambani were able to dominate critical industries by leveraging their business acumen and connections. They faced accusations of monopolistic behavior and were seen as benefiting from regulatory environments that allowed them to consolidate power.
The key difference lies in their industries and the regulatory responses in their respective countries. Slim’s telecommunications empire has been subject to more direct regulatory interventions. On the contrary, Ambani’s controversies were more about navigating and exploiting existing regulations rather than direct market control.
5. Mark Zuckerberg (Facebook)
Mark Zuckerberg has been embroiled in controversies related to data privacy, misinformation, and the platform’s role in influencing elections. The Cambridge Analytica scandal and other issues raised concerns about Facebook’s business practices and its impact on society.
Zuckerberg’s controversies revolved around the ethical implications of technology and data. On the other hand, Ambani’s were more about traditional business practices and market manipulation. Both, however, highlight the challenges of managing a business that holds significant influence over a large population. In both cases, the leaders were criticized for not adequately addressing the broader societal impacts of their business practices.
Final take
Dhirubhai Ambani’s rise to power is a testament to his business acumen, vision, and relentless pursuit of growth. However, his career was also marked by numerous controversies that raised questions about his business practices. While his contributions to the Indian economy are undeniable, the controversies surrounding his business practices continue to spark debate. However, Dhirubhai Ambani is both an inspiration and a cautionary tale for future generations of entrepreneurs.
How Pressfarm can help your business succeed
Need help building your personal brand and creating newsworthy content? Let the PR specialists, expert writers, and certified designers at Pressfarm help you.
Pressfarm is a PR agency that helps startups and companies of various sizes create quality content. Think email pitches, press releases, guest posts, and press kits. All of this content can help you build a memorable brand image. We can also distribute your content to respected media outlets and startup directories. In addition, we help you to feature in relevant search results across different search engines. With our curated media list, you connect and partner with the best journalists in your niche to share your story. The best part is that you get all this and more wrapped in one of three affordable packages.
